Re: [discuss] New Option for fd.io mailing lists: groups.io

Ed Warnicke <hagbard@...>
 

Joel,

We *sort* of moderate our discussions.  As an anti-spam measure currently, if you are not subscribed to a mailer, and have not been previously 'whitelisted', your email is 'held for moderation' by the LF staff, which take a quick look to see if you are a spammer, and if not, they add you to the whitelist.   Essentially we 'moderate' out spammers, but all other conversation is completely inbounds.

As to other features, part of the discussion is which features we want to take advantage of.  Delighted to have your input on that :)

Ed

On Thu, Dec 14, 2017 at 9:51 AM Joel Halpern <joel.halpern@...> wrote:

I like having good searchable archives.

 

I have to say that I am completely turned off by the end of the FAQ.  We don’t “moderate” any of our discussions.  And unless something is very strange, the use of groups.io vs mailman better not have any visible effect on participation in the email discussions.

 

Listing features like wikis seems also counter-productive.  I do not want us to have two separate wiki spaces. 

 

Polls would be nice once in a while (although doodle seems to work just fine for most folks.)

 

If we want calendaring, I would want it integrated in the wiki, not part of the mailing list.

 

Yours,

Joel

 

From: discuss-bounces@... [mailto:discuss-bounces@...] On Behalf Of Ed Warnicke
Sent: Thursday, December 14, 2017 10:45 AM
To: tsc@...; discuss@...; vpp-dev <vpp-dev@...>; csit-dev@...; cicn-dev@...; honeycomb-dev <honeycomb-dev@...>; deb_dpdk-dev@...; rpm_dpdk@...; nsh_sfc-dev@...; odp4vpp-dev@...; pma_tools-dev@...; puppet-fdio@...; tldk-dev@...; trex-dev@...
Subject: [discuss] New Option for fd.io mailing lists: groups.io

 

A new option has become available for handling mailing lists: groups.io

 

As a community, we need to look at this option, provide feedback, and come to a decision as to whether or not to migrate.  A critical part of that is having folks take a look, ask questions, and express opinions :)

 

We have a sandbox example at  https://groups.io/g/lfn  you can look at

 

And an example with active list and imported archive: https://lists.odpi.org/g/odpi-sig-bi

 

Major benefits include searchability, better web interface, etc.

 

The LF was kind enough to write a FAQ for us as we consider as a community whether to migrate or not:

 

FAQs

Q: What are the key differences between Mailman and Groups.io?

●Groups.io has a modern interface, robust user security model, and interactive, searchable archives

●Groups.io provides advanced features including muting threads and integrations with modern tools like GitHub, Slack, and Trello

●             Groups.io also has optional extras like a shared calendar, polling, chat, a wiki, and more

●             Groups.io uses a concept of subgroups, where members first join the project “group” (a master list), then they choose the specific “subgroup” lists they want to subscribe to

 

Q: How is the experience different for me as a list moderator or participant?

In many ways, it is very much the same. You will still find the main group at your existing URL and sub-groups equate to the more focused mailing lists based on the community’s needs. Here is an example of main group and sub-group URL patterns, and their respective emails:

 

 

What is different is Groups.io’s simple but highly functional UI that will make the experience of moderating or participating in the community discussions more enjoyable.

 

 

Join odp4vpp-dev@lists.fd.io to automatically receive all group messages.